french door fridge vs bottom freezer Door Refrigerator With Ice Maker Review

Melding form with functionality, french door fridge freezer with ice and water dispenser-door refrigerators have elegant double doors that open up to a spacious fridge up top and freezer drawer below. Special features like through-the-door dispensers, higher-end ice machines and flex drawers that can be customized make them stand out from the crowd.

We consulted experts such as Ladina Schopf, interior designer, architect, and founder of LS Projects, for tips on how to select the best one. They considered storage capacity and layout, energy efficiency, and other factors.

GE Profile Counter Depth French Door Refrigerator

As its name suggests, GE’s Profile series is aimed at consumers who want to incorporate cutting-edge technology into their kitchens. This refrigerator is packed with features, from an in-the-door Keurig K-cup coffee maker to a sophisticated water dispenser. But these flourishes don't mask mediocre performance, especially in the refrigerator's freezer and an ineffective temperature-controlled drawer. Given that this fridge costs a premium, I expect better.

Aside from that blip, this fridge is a great option. It features a large freezer compartment which is uncommon for counter-depth french door fridge small door fridges. It also holds plenty of frozen food compared to other models.

Inside the fridge, there are 17 shelves and compartments. The fridge compartment has 18.5 cubic feet, which is the standard for a French-door refrigerator at this price. It comes with a decent size refrigerator with an ice maker in the left door. But it's not the biggest one I've seen.

You can adjust the shelves in both compartments to make an individual storage solution. The GE PYE22PYNFS's design for the interior is good-looking, too. Its LED lighting is a nice addition, and the in-door storage bins feature an additional shelf that folds down to allow you to store large items. The drawers have temperature controls so that you can set them for Beverage, Meat, or Deli settings. The drawers are simple to open and shut, but I found the plastic's textured coatings to be a bit rough on my fingers.

The GE PGE29BYTFS Smart Refrigerator comes with all the features you would expect from a refrigerator within this price range. It has Wi-Fi as well as app support and GE's SmartHQ Software. The app is available on iOS and Android devices and allows you to control your refrigerator from any place around the world. It also has numerous options for customizing. It also alerts you when a door is left open, when the fridge or freezer needs defrosting and when it's time to change the filter.

It would be great it GE PYE22PYNFS offered Precise fill, an option that is available in a few GE refrigerators that allow users to set how many cups they want to disperse. The fridge displays a countdown to show you how much water remains, but it's not as effective as Precise Fill.

Bosch Counter Depth French Door Fridge Door Refrigerator

Created to appear like a seamless part of your kitchen Bosch's French-door refrigerator looks seamless and is one of a kind. The fridge uses fingerprint-resistant stainless steel, which is a great feature for busy households. It also boasts a veggie compartment to keep vegetables and fruits fresher for longer, and two compressors for the best food preservation. The Ice maker is among the best we've ever tested and produces a pyramid-shaped ice with a low water consumption. This fridge is ideal for a single family or kitchenette that needs an elegant design and top of the best food preservation.

This refrigerator was rated as the most efficient in our Refrigerators Test due to a variety of reasons. The temperature of the freezer remained stable at a level that was just above 0 degrees Fahrenheit, never moving more than a fraction a degree--this is key in preventing freezing burn. The fridge section of the fridge also performed well, achieving the temperature that was set for the initial setting within an hour and maintaining the temperature constant over the course of our tests.

Bosch is a household name for its high-end appliances. It's therefore no surprise that the Bosch counter depth fridge can be connected to your home Wi Fi and Bosch's platform Home Connect. This app lets you monitor and manage your fridge remotely using your tablet or smartphone. The refrigerator is pricey, but offers great features and capabilities at a reasonable price.

While the fridge is an amazing appliance, it's important to know the limitations. You may need to get inventive with tall items since the fridge has a limited shelf space. The shelves are also not impervious to spills fisher and paykel french door integrated fridge could easily be damaged or stained by sharp objects. It's easy to remove the trays in the fridge however, you must keep them clean to avoid the growth of mold.

If you're thinking of buying this refrigerator, be sure to look over our review of the French Door GE Appliances Refrigerator and the Bosch Bottom Freezer Refrigerator.

LG Counter Depth French Door Refrigerator

The LG LRFLC2706S counter-depth fridge is a great choice for those who require a lot of space in a small frame. It has a sleek, fingerprint-resistant stainless-steel finish and features thick handles that make them comfortable to grip. The fridge has an ordinary French door design, with two rows of spill-capture shelving and a set crisper drawers. The upper right shelf can be folded down to give tall items more space. There's also a full-width storage drawer for deli items and an internal water dispenser.

One of the great things about this refrigerator is that its ice maker is in the freezer, making it simple to move the ice to the refrigerator to be used when it is required. The freezer has thoughtful design elements, for instance, sliding drawers that help to organize the place of items. It also has a large container to store frozen food items, and a separate bin for ice.

Another awesome feature of this refrigerator is its Smart InstaView panel. It allows you to control the fridge's temperature, lighting, and more via your smartphone. It's a good way to monitor and manage your refrigerator, especially if you're away from home.

The Smart InstaView feature is neat, but it doesn't necessarily enhance the performance of the fridge. In fact it took longer to defrost and chill foods in this refrigerator as compared to other fridges we tried. This could be due to the bigger capacity.

The doors are a different issue with this refrigerator. The sunken handles allow shorter people to open them from the bottom. However taller people will struggle to close them without slamming them. It would have been much better to have front-mounted handles.

The LG Counter-Depth MAX fridge is an excellent choice for those who want to combine the look of a French door refrigerator with a more efficient design. Its capacity is superior for a counter-depth model, and it cools evenly and has a good layout. It's also less expensive than the best counter-depth refrigerators that have an ice maker, which can make it a desirable choice.

Frigidaire Counter Depth French Door Refrigerator

If you're looking for an French door refrigerator that won't cost a fortune this Frigidaire is a solid option. It's a basic design that's not as striking visually as other models however it comes with enough features that make it a great option. Its main feature is the adjustable temperature drawer which helps keep food items like meat and vegetables fresher for longer. It also has a large water dispenser, as well as an excellent ice machine that works fast.

The "Chill Drawer", which is located above the two crisper bins, is another excellent feature. This drawer lets you redirect some of the fridge's cooling power to the area so that you can keep food items which need extra attention. You can alter the feature using a slider that's located right on the outside of the drawer. You can also use this to set a general cooling setting for the entire fridge, though I've found that adjusting the generic settings tends to produce better results than specific ones.

During my tests, the refrigerator's temperatures were fairly constant across the different areas of the fridge. The temperatures in the top and bottom of the fridge did not vary very far from 38 degrees, and the middle of the fridge was within one degree of 36. That's a good performance, but it doesn't quite make it into the top ten in our rankings.

This fridge has a few other neat features, including a temperature-monitoring display that alerts you to fluctuations and provides a forecast for the day ahead. You can also connect this fridge to an intelligent thermometer to get more precise readings of your fridge's temperature.

The Frigidaire FGHB2866PF's outside is made of stainless steel with a grey-bodied body with a "smudge-proof" finish. It blocks streaks and fingerprints better than other stainless steel finishes I've tried.

Stephanie Cronk, executive editor of Reviewed's Commerce/Product Reviews Team, oversees the site’s buyer’s guides and product test reviews. She has more than 15 years of commerce and publishing experience, with a focus on retail and digital. Stephanie is passionate about finding and recommending the best products for consumers, with an emphasis on home products and tech.